School of Labor and Employment Relations Climate Jobs Institute

By Jane Gross

In her oral history, Jody Hogge proudly wore her blue United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) shirt while she talked about balancing the challenges of motherhood with the high risk profession of coal mining. Jody had a career before she entered mining – she happily worked at the P. R. Mallory factory in Pana, Illinois. While there, she joined the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers and fought for a raise as a member of the negotiating committee to increase the hourly wage to $3.00 per hour. Unfortunately, the strike was unsuccessful. “We walked picket for two or three weeks, I think. And then they just came in and moved everything out and they later tore the building down.” The factory moved to Tennessee and Jody lost the job she thought she would have for the rest of her life. This career setback led her to mining. 

In 1978, Jody became one of the first women to work in Peabody Mine #10. Her youngest child was six years old. Coal mining was a major industry in the Taylorville area, yet women rarely voluntarily worked in mines until forced desegregation in the mid-1970s. She knew from her time at P. R. Mallory that active union participation was essential for workplace progress, but it took a few years for her to meaningfully participate in her local union. “I didn’t go for the first two years because the first meeting I went to and got sworn in, there was two or three [members] that was drunk there. We didn’t even get much of anything done.” 

She wasn’t alone in eschewing union duties; her female coworkers weren’t participating either. Jody’s experience was common in gendered work spaces. Labor scholar Marion Crain conducted a survey in the early 1990s to better understand union organizing. She found a gendered-approach that was “sensitive to women’s family obligations in scheduling meetings, and [took] advantage of acculturated patterns in social interactions to create comfortable and welcoming conditions for organizing meetings” helped increase women’s union involvement (Crain, 1994, 240). 

The barriers to participation were even greater in the 1970s and 1980s when Jody was working in the mine. Indeed, she talked about how welcomed she felt by women’s groups in her oral history. She built an international network of women miners who encouraged her to advocate for improvements and inclusive representation within her local union. While she said “[m]y kids probably is what I’m most proud of,” she also found a great deal of pride in “working for this, this union and getting to know so many people, through the union and through the women miners.”

Listening to Jody’s story, it is evident how transitions are experienced differently according to one’s identity, specifically their gender. Jody’s life was a series of transitions: school to marriage to motherhood to the workforce. Her transition from one stage to the next was not always smooth, nor were the stages discrete. Each transition carried remnants of her past. For example, she participated in labor strikes as both a worker and mother. She brought her four-year-old son with her to the relatively tame picketline at the P. R. Mallory factory to join the other mothers striking with their children. 

Similarly, decarbonization is not a rupture from the underlying racial, gender, and socioeconomic inequalities in our society. Transitioning away from carbon is not necessarily a “just” transition. Working mothers like Jody face obstacles that will continue into a decarbonized future unless justice guides decisionmaking. A Just Transition framework specifically recognizes how systematic oppression leads to different experiences within the energy transition, and identifying ways to lessen those inequalities is necessary to improve outcomes for women, mothers, and society at large. 

By telling her story, Jody is preserving the work of women within social movements and coal workers within labor history. Jody participated in traditional social movement efforts like strikes and non-violent protests as a worker, but her day-to-day actions in retirement continue to support the labor movement. Communication scholars Christina R. Foust and Raisa Alvarado (2018) outline the growing understanding of “social movements as verbs, processes always occurring and in flux” (16). 

Jody communicating a desire for greater acknowledgement of the lasting impact of coal workers on society and laborers today – through her dual identity as a woman and a former coal miner – is an act that moves and shapes the public. “Now that we’re a retiree local, if somebody passes away in the general area…I try to do the funerals.” Reading memorials at her fellow laborer’s funerals is another one of Jody’s day-to-day actions that keeps the labor movement alive. I view capturing Jody’s story as an act of preservation that moves the social because it introduces a new generation to the struggles women coal miners have overcome. 

I knew little about coal mining’s labor history before joining this project, so I learned a great deal from Jody about UMWA and the experience underground. I am a social science researcher working on my PhD in Natural Resources and Environmental Sciences, so I was obviously drawn to the environmental and public health aspects of Jody’s story. Jody’s story was most impactful to me, however, because it echoed what I have heard from other women in male-dominated spaces. 

I interact with women farmers and landowners in Illinois as part of my dissertation research. Hearing about the different roles for women in the mine made me think immediately of the different roles for women on the farm. While the landscape is changing, it was – and often remains – common to not prepare daughters to take over the farm. Women from farming backgrounds have expressed frustration over the ways in which sexism has reduced their ability to participate fully as stewards of the land, and listening to Jody was a reminder that this gendered experience extends beyond the farm field. 

More personally, I felt a connection to Jody because she spoke a language that is well-known to children from blue collar families like mine. Concerns over workplace injuries, gratitude for and disappointment in unions, tradeoffs between childcare and shift work – these are all routine topics of discussion in working-class communities. Ultimately, listening to Jody’s oral history reaffirmed my understanding that a just transition must include the experiences of the people who have experienced marginalization due to gender, class, race, or other vulnerabilities. I listened to oral histories from male mine workers after Jody, and none of their stories touched on the discrimination women faced in the mine that Jody described in her oral history. 

Kuntala Lahiri-Dutt (2023) argues “[if] Just Transition(s) should extend beyond job protection to encompass radical social transformations and the restructuring of market-based economies to reduce existing socioeconomic inequities, then gender should become a part of the long-term planning and commitment” (4). This project has helped me connect my personal experience and research expertise to the broader environmental, social, and labor movements in Illinois by strengthening my understanding of how the shared experiences women face must be recognized within our just transition.   

References

Crain, Marion. “Gender and Union Organizing.” Industrial & Labor Relations Review 47, no. 2 (1994): 227–48. https://doi.org/10.1177/001979399404700205. 

Foust, Christina R, and Raisa Alvarado. “Rhetoric and Social Movements” in Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Communication, edited by Matthew Powers. Oxford Academic, 2018. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228613.013.656 

Lahiri-Dutt, Kuntala. “Framing a Gender Transformative post-coal future for just transition: A feminist manifesto.” Energy Research & Social Science 100 (2023): 103097. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2023.103097 

In 2025, Jody Hogge recorded an oral history for the Illinois Coal Workers & Communities Listening Project. This article includes stories and memories narrated during the recording of her oral history. The Listening Project oral history collection will be made publicly available in 2028.

The Climate Jobs Institute at the University of Illinois leads the Illinois Coal Workers & Communities Listening Project in partnership with experts from the Harlem High School Documentary Project, Prairie Rivers Network, Department of Urban & Regional Planning, Labor Education Program, Illinois Extension, and Humanities Research Institute. The Listening Project learns from Illinois coal workers, their families, and communities impacted by mine and plant closures — preserving their stories and informing policies for a just energy transition.

The Illinois Coal Workers & Communities Listening Project is funded by the State of Illinois, through an appropriation to the Climate Jobs Institute.

Jody Hogge’s oral history was recorded by Emily Guske (Climate Jobs Institute, lead interviewer), Magdalena Novoa (Department of Urban & Regional Planning, secondary interviewer), Johnathan Hettinger (Climate Jobs Institute, secondary interviewer), and Jordan Woodward (Humanities Research Institute, camera and audio).

Banner Image: Jody Hogge records her oral history for the Illinois Coal Workers & Communities Listening Project at the Moose Lodge #1516 in Taylorville on October 13, 2025. Photo taken from recorded interview.

School of Labor and Employment Relations Climate Jobs Institute

504 E. Armory Avenue
Champaign, IL 61820

Phone: (217) 333-1482

Email: climate-jobs@illinois.edu

Quick Links